Granite vs Quartz vs Quartzite: Choosing the Perfect Kitchen Countertop

Your kitchen countertops endure more daily abuse than any other surface in your home. They face hot pots, sharp knives, spilled wine, acidic foods, and constant use—all while serving as the visual centerpiece of your kitchen.

After 50+ years installing thousands of countertops across Monmouth and Ocean Counties, we've seen trends come and go. But three materials consistently dominate: granite, quartz, and quartzite.

Each offers distinct advantages. Each suits different lifestyles, budgets, and aesthetics. And choosing the wrong one can mean years of frustration, costly maintenance, or regret.

This comprehensive guide compares granite, quartz, and quartzite across every factor that matters—durability, maintenance, cost, heat resistance, aesthetics, and real-world performance in New Jersey homes.

Whether you're planning a kitchen remodel in Rumson, Holmdel, or anywhere in Monmouth County, this guide ensures you choose the right countertop for your needs.

---

Understanding Each Material

Granite: Classic Natural Stone

What It Is: Igneous rock formed from cooled magma deep in the earth, cut into slabs and polished.

Composition: Natural stone—primarily quartz and feldspar with mica, amphibole minerals

Appearance: Natural variations, unique patterns per slab, range of colors from subtle to dramatic

History: Been used for thousands of years; dominated kitchen countertops 1990s-2010s

Quartz: Engineered Stone

What It Is: Manufactured surface combining ground natural quartz with polymer resins and pigments.

Composition: 90-95% ground natural quartz + 5-10% polyester resins and pigments

Appearance: Consistent patterns, wide color range, can mimic marble or granite, some sparkle from quartz crystals

History: Introduced 1980s; gained massive popularity 2010s+; now most popular countertop material

Quartzite: Premium Natural Stone

What It Is: Metamorphic rock formed when sandstone undergoes extreme heat and pressure.

Composition: Natural stone—primarily quartz that has been transformed and recrystallized

Appearance: Dramatic natural veining, often resembles marble, luxury aesthetic, unique per slab

History: Ancient stone; recent surge in popularity as marble alternative (harder, more durable)

Critical Note: True quartzite is different from "soft quartzite"—verify with fabricator that you're getting real quartzite.

---

Detailed Comparison: Granite vs Quartz vs Quartzite

Durability & Hardness

Quartz: 7 on Mohs Hardness Scale

• Extremely scratch-resistant


• Chip-resistant (resin provides some flexibility)


• Won't crack under normal use


• Performs excellently in high-traffic kitchens

Granite: 6-7 on Mohs Hardness Scale

• Very scratch-resistant


• Can chip if struck hard


• Durable for decades with care


• Strong performance in most kitchens

Quartzite: 7 on Mohs Hardness Scale

• Hardest natural stone countertop option


• Extremely scratch and chip resistant


• Virtually indestructible with proper care


• Ideal for heavy-use kitchens

Winner: Quartzite for pure hardness, quartz for overall durability in daily use

Maintenance Requirements

Quartz: Ultra-Low Maintenance

• Sealing: Never needs sealing (non-porous)


• Daily Care: Soap and water


• Stain Resistance: Excellent (resists wine, coffee, oils)


• Bacteria Resistance: Excellent (non-porous)


• Annual Maintenance: None required

Granite: Moderate Maintenance

• Sealing: Every 1-3 years depending on porosity


• Daily Care: Mild soap and water, wipe spills quickly


• Stain Resistance: Good (when properly sealed)


• Bacteria Resistance: Good (when sealed)


• Annual Maintenance: Test seal, reseal if needed

Quartzite: Moderate-High Maintenance

• Sealing: Every 1-2 years (sometimes more frequently)


• Daily Care: Gentle cleaners, immediate spill cleanup


• Stain Resistance: Moderate (porous, can stain if not sealed)


• Bacteria Resistance: Good when sealed


• Annual Maintenance: Regular sealing, careful handling of acids

Winner: Quartz—requires virtually zero maintenance

See our countertop installation services for professional installation.

Heat Resistance

Granite: Excellent

• Natural stone withstands high heat


• Can place hot pots directly (though trivets recommended)


• Won't discolor or burn from heat


• Ideal for serious cooks

Quartzite: Excellent

• Superior heat resistance


• Handles hot pots well


• Natural stone means no resin to burn


• Great for avid home chefs

Quartz: Moderate

• Resin binders can discolor/burn above 300°F


• Always use trivets for hot pots


• Not recommended for placing hot items directly


• Can crack from thermal shock

Winner: Granite and quartzite for heat resistance

Stain Resistance

Quartz: Excellent

• Non-porous surface resists all stains


• Wine, coffee, oil won't penetrate


• Minimal risk even with delayed cleanup


• Best for families and entertainers

Granite: Good (When Sealed)

• Sealed granite resists most stains


• Acidic foods (lemon, tomato) can etch if left


• Oil can penetrate if seal is worn


• Requires prompt spill cleanup

Quartzite: Moderate

• Can stain if not properly sealed


• Acidic foods can etch surface


• Requires immediate attention to spills


• Needs regular sealing for protection

Winner: Quartz—virtually stain-proof

Aesthetic Options

Granite:

• Patterns: Natural, unique per slab


• Colors: Browns, blacks, whites, reds, blues, greens


• Style: Classic, traditional to contemporary


• Variation: High—each slab unique


• Best For: Traditional kitchens, natural organic look

Quartz:

• Patterns: Consistent, can mimic marble/granite/concrete


• Colors: Nearly unlimited (pure whites to blacks)


• Style: Contemporary to traditional


• Variation: Patterns repeat every 6-8 feet


• Best For: Clean modern look, consistent aesthetic

Quartzite:

• Patterns: Dramatic natural veining (often marble-like)


• Colors: Whites, grays, golds, subtle earth tones


• Style: Luxury, high-end


• Variation: Extremely high—one-of-a-kind slabs


• Best For: Statement pieces, luxury homes, marble look with durability

Popular Choices in Monmouth County:

• Quartz: White Attica, Calacatta Laza, Statuario Nuvo


• Granite: Colonial White, Absolute Black, Kashmir White


• Quartzite: Taj Mahal, Fantasy Brown, Sea Pearl

Winner: Tie—depends on aesthetic preference

Cost Comparison (Monmouth County Pricing)

Granite:

• Material: $40-80/sq ft


• Installation: $20-40/sq ft


• Total Installed: $60-120/sq ft


• 50 sq ft kitchen: $3,000-6,000

Quartz:

• Material: $50-100/sq ft


• Installation: $25-50/sq ft


• Total Installed: $75-150/sq ft


• 50 sq ft kitchen: $3,750-7,500

Quartzite:

• Material: $70-140/sq ft


• Installation: $30-60/sq ft


• Total Installed: $100-200/sq ft


• 50 sq ft kitchen: $5,000-10,000

Additional Costs:

• Edge details: $10-50/linear foot (waterfall, ogee, custom)


• Cutouts: $100-300 each (sink, cooktop)


• Backsplash: $60-120/sq ft if matching material

Winner: Granite for budget-conscious, quartz for value

Learn more about kitchen remodeling costs in NJ.

Resale Value

Quartz:

• Highly desirable to buyers


• "Low maintenance" is major selling point


• Modern appeal


• Strong ROI in all price ranges

Granite:

• Still popular, slightly less trendy


• Classic choice buyers expect


• Good ROI in mid-range homes


• Less impressive in luxury markets

Quartzite:

• Premium positioning


• Strongest appeal in luxury homes ($800K+)


• Differentiator in upscale markets


• Best ROI in high-end Rumson, Colts Neck, Spring Lake

Winner: Quartz for broad appeal, quartzite for luxury homes

---

Which Countertop is Right for You?

Choose QUARTZ if you:

✓ Want zero-maintenance countertops ✓ Have a busy family or entertain frequently ✓ Prefer consistent patterns and colors ✓ Want stain and bacteria resistance ✓ Seek best value (performance per dollar) ✓ Like contemporary or transitional styles

Best Quartz Brands: Cambria, Caesarstone, Silestone, Hanstone

Choose GRANITE if you:

✓ Want classic natural stone ✓ Love unique, one-of-a-kind patterns ✓ Are comfortable with periodic sealing ✓ Work within a tighter budget ✓ Prefer traditional or rustic kitchens ✓ Want excellent heat resistance

Best Granite Types: Kashmir White, Black Galaxy, Absolute Black, Colonial White

Choose QUARTZITE if you:

✓ Want luxury natural stone with marble aesthetic ✓ Prioritize durability above all else ✓ Are willing to maintain with regular sealing ✓ Have a larger budget ($100-200/sq ft) ✓ Want a true showpiece countertop ✓ Love dramatic natural veining

Best Quartzite Types: Taj Mahal, Fantasy Brown, White Macaubas, Sea Pearl

---

Common Myths Debunked

Myth 1: "Quartz looks fake compared to natural stone"

Reality: Modern quartz technology creates incredibly realistic marble and granite looks. While it's true patterns repeat, in a typical kitchen you won't notice. High-end quartz (Cambria, Caesarstone) rivals natural stone aesthetics.

Myth 2: "Granite is outdated"

Reality: Granite remains popular in 2026, especially in traditional homes. While quartz has overtaken it in market share, granite's natural beauty and lower cost keep it relevant.

Myth 3: "Quartzite is low maintenance like quartz"

Reality: Despite the similar name, quartzite is a natural stone requiring regular sealing. It's NOT the same as quartz (engineered stone).

Myth 4: "You can put hot pots on any countertop"

Reality: Only granite and quartzite handle heat well. Quartz can discolor, burn, or crack from hot pans. Always use trivets on quartz.

Myth 5: "Granite harbors bacteria"

Reality: Properly sealed granite is non-porous and doesn't harbor bacteria more than other surfaces. Quartz has a slight edge as engineered non-porous, but sealed granite is perfectly hygienic.

---

Real Monmouth County Homeowner Experiences

Quartz in Family Kitchen, Holmdel:
"We chose Cambria quartz for our remodel. With three kids and constant cooking, it's been perfect. Wine spills, tomato sauce, homework markers—nothing stains. Five years in and it looks brand new with zero maintenance." —Jennifer M.

Granite in Traditional Colonial, Red Bank:
"We wanted authentic natural stone to match our 1920s colonial. Kashmir White granite was the perfect choice—classic, durable, affordable. We seal it once a year, takes 20 minutes. Worth it for the real stone beauty." —David L.

Quartzite Waterfall Island, Rumson:
"Our kitchen needed a showpiece. Taj Mahal quartzite with waterfall edges is absolutely stunning—guests always comment. Yes, we seal it twice a year and are careful with lemons, but the beauty is worth the extra care." —Patricia R.

---

Installation Considerations

Fabrication Complexity

Quartz:

• Easier to fabricate than natural stone


• Consistent thickness and density


• Can create seamless look


• Fewer breakage issues

Granite:

• Requires skilled fabricator


• Natural fissures require careful handling


• Pattern matching needed for visible seams


• Some risk of breakage during fabrication

Quartzite:

• Most difficult to fabricate


• Extremely hard (wears down tools faster)


• Requires expert fabricator


• Higher labor costs due to difficulty

Seam Visibility

Quartz: Seams can be nearly invisible with good fabrication (pattern matching)

Granite: Seams visible due to natural variation (strategic placement important)

Quartzite: Seams very visible due to unique patterns (plan carefully)

Lead Times

Quartz: 2-3 weeks (manufactured, more available)

Granite: 2-4 weeks (depends on slab availability)

Quartzite: 3-6 weeks (limited availability, imported)

---

Monmouth County Kitchen Remodeling Experts

At Custom Kitchens by Lopez, we help homeowners select the perfect countertop for their kitchen, lifestyle, and budget.

Our Process:
✓ Visit our showroom to see full slabs in person
✓ Bring samples home to see in your lighting
✓ Discuss your cooking habits and maintenance preferences
✓ Review pros/cons of each material for your specific needs
✓ Provide detailed estimates for granite, quartz, and quartzite
✓ Coordinate with trusted fabricators for expert installation

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Call us today: 732.984.1043

---

Related Resources

• Kitchen Island Ideas
• Kitchen Remodeling Trends 2026
• Countertop Installation Services

Service Areas:

• Kitchen Remodeling Rumson


• Kitchen Remodeling Holmdel


• Kitchen Remodeling Colts Neck

---

Custom Kitchens by Lopez | NJ License #13VH04175700 | 50+ Years Family Owned | 5.0★ Google Rating

Helping Monmouth County homeowners choose the perfect kitchen countertops since 1974